My team is getting re-org’ed. You can’t go six months in Microsoft without getting re-org’ed. It shouldn’t affect us much though. We’ll see..
Even though our team is about to swallow another team, we’re still actively hiring. So I’ll pose a hypothetical question (which I don’t necessarily face at the moment, but I’ve always wondered how to act faced with this scenario).
Let’s say someone you know (ie. from some established relationship–be it a friendship, prior working relationship, or even a familial relationship) asks you if there are any openings in your company and/or team. If you respect that person and/or believe that that person has qualities that would be beneficial to your organization, then it is a non-issue. But if you personally don’t believe that person has got what it takes, then what do you do? You can:
- Pass it on to the people in charge (HR/hiring manager); They can deal with the person.
- Tell the person to look elsewhere: "There aren’t any [good] openings here right now."
- Do nothing, but tell the person you contacted the right people.
- Tell the person they aren’t good enough.
The problem with (1) is that not only do they place strain on HR or hiring manager, if your friend does get hired, you might have to work with him/her. Plus side here is that you might get a referral bonus.. haha.
The problem with (3) is that it is inherently dishonest. I know at least one person that went down this route and didn’t find issue with it though. Not to mention that it is fairly egotistical to judge others and personally bar entry.
And (2) is similar to (3). Who are you to judge? You essentially brush them off without being dishonest.
And with (4)? Say goodbye to your friendship.
The farther you go down this list, the bigger your ego is. At issue is the distinction between a working relationship from all other relationships. Just because you consider a person a friend doesn’t necessarily mean that they would be a good person to work with. So how do you keep these separate?
It’s an interesting little dilemma. Personally I choose the lesser of four evils: #(2).
There’s also the flip side of the coin to consider. What happens when I am out there in the market and I call on my friends?